Exposure Therapy: Enhancing fear extinction
Memories of aversive or negative events are central to the survival of animals. However, fear learning and memory can become a challenge in people with certain conditions, such as specific phobias, anxiety or PTSD. Such individuals often avoid certain activities or situations, or start to transfer their fear to new stimuli. This avoidance strategy may help reduce fear in the short term, but but it can increase distress in the long term.
One method to alleviate fear is exposure therapy, in which individuals are subjected to objects or situations they are afraid of in a safe environment, without experiencing harm (Craske et al., 2018). For example, for someone with a fear of dogs, exposure-based therapy might include looking at pictures of dogs. This will initially produce a fear response that can include physiological changes, such as perspiration and elevated heart rate, and psychological changes, such as an increase in subjective fear. After several exposures to these stimuli, both physiological and psychological indices of fear will decline.
While this ‘extinction’ method is highly effective in minimizing fear in the short term, fear reduced through this method is highly susceptible to relapse. Even patients and subjects showing no signs of fear at the end of therapy are likely to experience a rebound after a certain amount of time or when they are re-exposed to the distressing stimulus (Bouton et al., 2021; Vervliet et al., 2013).
Decades of research suggests that this re-appearance of symptoms happens because extinction creates a new inhibitory memory that competes with – rather than updates – the original fear memory. Recent learning theories suggest that learned events are assigned a ‘prediction error’: if the prediction error is large (i.e., the new experience differs greatly from the past one) a new association will be formed. But if the prediction error is small (and the new experience is similar to the past one), the existing memory will be updated or overwritten with new information. Since fear- and anxiety-based disorders are on the rise, identifying intervention and treatment strategies to mitigate fear in a long term, relapse-resistant manner is therefore of upmost importance (Jacob et al., 2021; Siegel et al., 2022).
Now, in eLife, Nathan Holmes and colleagues – including Nicholas Kennedy as first author – report evidence that supports this recent learning theory (Kennedy et al., 2024). Kennedy et al. used a classical conditioning protocol in which they conditioned rats to fear a tone (conditional stimulus) by pairing its presentation with a brief electric shock applied to the foot (unconditional stimulus). Following this training, rats responded with freezing to the tone alone.
The researchers then used two different procedures to reduce the rats’ fear. The first group received a ‘standard’ extinction procedure during which the rats were exposed to several presentations of the sound only. The second group received a new ‘gradual’ extinction procedure, during which the tone was paired with a gradually weakened shock voltage: from 0.8 to 0.4, 0.2, and 0.1 mA. While both the traditional and gradual extinction lessened the fear response, the gradual procedure was able to also reduce relapse.
Relapse was tested at different time points following extinction treatment. When animals were re-exposed to the tone two weeks after the extinction procedures, the traditional group showed an increase in fear (e.g., more freezing) while the gradual extinction group showed less fear. The gradual extinction group was also less likely to relapse even when the animals received a brief foot shock without sound (known as ‘reinstatement’) after the extinction treatment. However, both groups were similarly susceptible to relapse if there was a change in environmental conditions from conditioning to extinction, for example, changing the physical chamber or waiting a long time between conditioning and extinction (Figure 1). Thus, the efficacy of gradual extinction relies on similar contextual parameters during conditioning and extinction to optimally minimize relapse.
Collectively, these results add to a growing literature that suggests manipulating the intensity of an unconditional stimulus (such as an electric shock) following training can have a substantial advantage over standard extinction treatments in reducing fear long-term. Kennedy et al. provide a clear explanation for these results that supports recent learning theories: too much variation between the original training shock and what occurs during extinction (as experienced in the standard group) is more likely to create a new inhibitory memory. On the other hand, a smaller change (as is experienced in the gradual extinction group) is more likely to weaken aspects of the original memory and is thus able to reduce fear long term.
These results present a promising first step in increasing the efficacy of extinction-based treatments. A next step will be to test the neural mechanisms that contribute to this effect to determine if and how this process differs from standard extinction practices, and if it could in fact be more similar to other processes relevant for updating memory, such as reconsolidation.
References
-
State-of-the-art and future directions for extinction as a translational model for fear and anxietyPhilosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London. Series B, Biological Sciences 373:20170025.https://doi.org/10.1098/rstb.2017.0025
-
Impact of the coronavirus 2019 (COVID-19) pandemic on anxiety diagnosis in general practices in GermanyJournal of Psychiatric Research 143:528–533.https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jpsychires.2020.11.029
-
Nothing to fear but fear itself: a mechanistic test of unconscious exposureBiological Psychiatry 91:294–302.https://doi.org/10.1016/j.biopsych.2021.08.022
-
Fear extinction and relapse: state of the artAnnual Review of Clinical Psychology 9:215–248.https://doi.org/10.1146/annurev-clinpsy-050212-185542
Article and author information
Author details
Publication history
- Version of Record published: April 15, 2024 (version 1)
Copyright
© 2024, Trask and Ferrara
This article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use and redistribution provided that the original author and source are credited.
Metrics
-
- 378
- views
-
- 39
- downloads
-
- 0
- citations
Views, downloads and citations are aggregated across all versions of this paper published by eLife.
Download links
Downloads (link to download the article as PDF)
Open citations (links to open the citations from this article in various online reference manager services)
Cite this article (links to download the citations from this article in formats compatible with various reference manager tools)
Further reading
-
- Neuroscience
Nociceptive sensory neurons convey pain-related signals to the CNS using action potentials. Loss-of-function mutations in the voltage-gated sodium channel NaV1.7 cause insensitivity to pain (presumably by reducing nociceptor excitability) but clinical trials seeking to treat pain by inhibiting NaV1.7 pharmacologically have struggled. This may reflect the variable contribution of NaV1.7 to nociceptor excitability. Contrary to claims that NaV1.7 is necessary for nociceptors to initiate action potentials, we show that nociceptors can achieve similar excitability using different combinations of NaV1.3, NaV1.7, and NaV1.8. Selectively blocking one of those NaV subtypes reduces nociceptor excitability only if the other subtypes are weakly expressed. For example, excitability relies on NaV1.8 in acutely dissociated nociceptors but responsibility shifts to NaV1.7 and NaV1.3 by the fourth day in culture. A similar shift in NaV dependence occurs in vivo after inflammation, impacting ability of the NaV1.7-selective inhibitor PF-05089771 to reduce pain in behavioral tests. Flexible use of different NaV subtypes exemplifies degeneracy – achieving similar function using different components – and compromises reliable modulation of nociceptor excitability by subtype-selective inhibitors. Identifying the dominant NaV subtype to predict drug efficacy is not trivial. Degeneracy at the cellular level must be considered when choosing drug targets at the molecular level.
-
- Neuroscience
Despite substantial progress in mapping the trajectory of network plasticity resulting from focal ischemic stroke, the extent and nature of changes in neuronal excitability and activity within the peri-infarct cortex of mice remains poorly defined. Most of the available data have been acquired from anesthetized animals, acute tissue slices, or infer changes in excitability from immunoassays on extracted tissue, and thus may not reflect cortical activity dynamics in the intact cortex of an awake animal. Here, in vivo two-photon calcium imaging in awake, behaving mice was used to longitudinally track cortical activity, network functional connectivity, and neural assembly architecture for 2 months following photothrombotic stroke targeting the forelimb somatosensory cortex. Sensorimotor recovery was tracked over the weeks following stroke, allowing us to relate network changes to behavior. Our data revealed spatially restricted but long-lasting alterations in somatosensory neural network function and connectivity. Specifically, we demonstrate significant and long-lasting disruptions in neural assembly architecture concurrent with a deficit in functional connectivity between individual neurons. Reductions in neuronal spiking in peri-infarct cortex were transient but predictive of impairment in skilled locomotion measured in the tapered beam task. Notably, altered neural networks were highly localized, with assembly architecture and neural connectivity relatively unaltered a short distance from the peri-infarct cortex, even in regions within ‘remapped’ forelimb functional representations identified using mesoscale imaging with anaesthetized preparations 8 weeks after stroke. Thus, using longitudinal two-photon microscopy in awake animals, these data show a complex spatiotemporal relationship between peri-infarct neuronal network function and behavioral recovery. Moreover, the data highlight an apparent disconnect between dramatic functional remapping identified using strong sensory stimulation in anaesthetized mice compared to more subtle and spatially restricted changes in individual neuron and local network function in awake mice during stroke recovery.